The Daily Static
  The Daily Static
UF Archives
Register
UF Membership
Ad Free Site
Postcards
Community

Geekfinder
UFie Gear
Advertise on UF

Forum Rules
& FAQ


Username

Password


Create a New Account

 
 

Back to UserFriendly Strip Comments Index

Why I am staying *AWAY* from SSDs! by jaqie2009-03-31 01:22:40
  Feh. I have the Intel (the X25-M). It's awesome. by firehawk 2009-03-31 02:32:20
I note that the Intel starts off being far more silly-stupid-fast than the competitors, and restores to a much better state after "seasoning", still silly-stupid-fast.

Here's the method I did, and I recommend it: get the Intel, put the OS on it, and put everything else on a fast hard drive or RAID 0 pair. Make sure the pagefile/swap is not on the SSD. Anything else of a very temporary write-heavy nature, get it off the SSD if you can.

It still runs silly-stupid-fast and makes Win7 run like it's as lean as DOS. Ditto with Vista. Linux (on my RAID 0 pair of WD 640MB "black" drives) feels slow, and I know from experience that it would at least match Win7's speed, if not surpass it, all other factors being equal.

If you read the later parts of the article carefully, it's not planned obsolescence, it's just a different type of drive with different requirements that OS's just don't support yet.

Observe this quote from the "verdict":

In using the X25-M I’d say that the performance drop was noticeable but not a deal breaker - and the data tends to agree with me. With average write latencies still well under 1ms, the drive maintained its most important performance characteristic - the ability to perform random accesses much faster than a conventional hard drive.

[...]

You end up with a drive that still manages to be much faster than the fastest 3.5” hard drives, but slower than when you first got it.

[...]

I still believe that a SSD is the single most effective performance upgrade you can do to your PC; even while taking this behavior into account. While personally I wouldn’t give up a SSD in any of my machines, I can understand the hesitation in investing a great deal of money in one today.

I believe he's saying that he's still in favor of this upgrade, as long as one is aware of the behavior going in, and takes adequate steps to make it easier to "season" the drive whenever it becomes necessary.

I can tell you this: I've had it in heavy use for 3 months now, and have noticed no drop in performance yet.

[ Reply ]
    10,000 writes max by jaqie2009-03-31 02:48:08
      addendum: by jaqie2009-03-31 02:56:03
        Definetely no replacement for *data* HDs yet. by aix tom2009-03-31 03:01:01
          I agree. by firehawk2009-03-31 03:08:47
            Yep. by aix tom2009-03-31 03:12:41
            <Deleted><Deleted>2009-03-31 03:20:01
              Mod'd: Double (n/t) by Tyop2009-03-31 03:20:17
            So you agree with him but not with me by jaqie2009-03-31 03:25:04
              What the h%$l is this? by jaqie2009-03-31 03:46:49
                Step back and take a breath. by firehawk2009-03-31 04:37:22
                A big misunderstanding between two tired people? by FNORDer2009-03-31 05:43:38
                  thanks by jaqie2009-03-31 05:59:13
                    While I am male... by FNORDer2009-03-31 06:07:53
                      O.o huh? by jaqie2009-03-31 06:12:44
                        I'd gathered as much. by FNORDer2009-03-31 06:18:40
              Limited use!=complete dismissal. by OsteSpiser2009-03-31 04:47:05
                So I didn't say "when used as a HDD replacement" by jaqie2009-03-31 05:01:47
                  "Why I am staying *AWAY* from SSDs! " by PSYCHOI3OY2009-03-31 05:08:40
                    I don't understand your point. by jaqie2009-03-31 05:12:41
                      I don't want to get in the middle of the debate by PSYCHOI3OY2009-03-31 05:26:59
                        Did you miss by jaqie2009-03-31 05:34:28
                          Ok, I see that now by PSYCHOI3OY2009-03-31 05:49:26
                          {{{{everyone}}}} by aix tom2009-03-31 05:52:25
                            lol (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 06:05:55
                            you mean I've gotta stop baiting the BSD and OS/2 by FNORDer2009-03-31 06:15:13
            Swap is the quickest way to kill Flash by intrinsic2009-03-31 05:53:58
              that's part of why I just upped to 8GB ram (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 06:04:53
          current consumer motherboards allow for by jaqie2009-03-31 03:10:26
            Trust me...just normal operation flies. by firehawk2009-03-31 03:20:49
              as compared to ram writes? (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 03:23:14
              Have you ever tried Puppy Linux? by djones99602009-03-31 05:58:38
                DSL can do that and is even faster by jaqie2009-03-31 06:03:59
                  Does it let you save changes between boots? nt by djones99602009-03-31 06:15:42
                    you can burn changes to disc by jaqie2009-03-31 06:18:54
                      Cool by djones99602009-03-31 06:21:48
                        easily added with a .dsl addon file by jaqie2009-03-31 06:22:47
                How much RAM does it need? (n/t) by MatthewDBA2009-03-31 06:13:24
                  seeing as how it doesn't fill a 700MB CD... (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 06:15:32
                    I'm still barely getting used to by MatthewDBA2009-03-31 06:19:43
                      I just went from 1.5GB to 8GB I hear yah! (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 06:21:02
                        Actually, going from by MatthewDBA2009-03-31 06:30:16
                          I use PC games to keep my sanity by jaqie2009-03-31 06:38:58
            ah, so win 7 will live without swap? by Freakazoid2009-03-31 06:55:48
              see for yourself by jaqie2009-03-31 07:07:30
                Nice wallpaper by confused.brit2009-03-31 12:35:50
                  no. (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 14:23:07
        Sorry, but you're proceeding from a flawed premise by firehawk2009-03-31 03:05:35
          AGAIN you misinterpret me by jaqie2009-03-31 03:24:00
      (these drives) I meant the SSDs (n/t) by jaqie2009-03-31 03:00:13
      INCORRECT. write != erase by firehawk2009-03-31 03:03:49
        You misinterpreted me by jaqie2009-03-31 03:22:32
          Why would someone assume you meant by merlin2009-03-31 07:02:12
            what the heck? by jaqie2009-03-31 07:09:43
              Not trying to stir up anything. Just pointing by merlin2009-03-31 07:11:58
          I've had terrible luck with drives by jayfarm2009-03-31 07:23:48
            wow id like to know by jaqie2009-03-31 07:28:24
      This is why you should NEVER put a page file on an by intrinsic2009-03-31 05:47:16
        no but there are tons of by jaqie2009-03-31 06:02:48

 

[Todays Cartoon Discussion] [News Index]

Come get yer ARS (Account Registration System) Source Code here!
All images, characters, content and text are copyrighted and trademarks of J.D. Frazer except where other ownership applies. Don't do bad things, we have lawyers.
UserFriendly.Org and its operators are not liable for comments or content posted by its visitors, and will cheerfully assist the lawful authorities in hunting down script-kiddies, spammers and other net scum. And if you're really bad, we'll call your mom. (We're not kidding, we've done it before.)